Yu-Gi-Oh! 3D Bonds Beyond Time

[Starry]

That being said, I would so use the Synchro Summon unreleased theme from the first 12 episodes if I had a better rip of it.

If it helps somebody did do a pretty damn good recreation on niconico :<.

[GoldenUmi]

Yeah, your wicked grudge choice was awesome. But I'm not sure what else I could use to replace the Millennium Kingdom track. Honestly the opening theme for me is fine so my mind hasn't really thought much in regards to what theme to put there. I'll have to get back to you on that one XD

I love Jose's theme, but I felt it took up too much time and being split up like it was was kind of awkward to me.

See, I have to adamantly disagree.

I just... hate the GX remix of Passionate Duelists because it sounds so utterly empty and lazy in terms of its instrumental arrangement and melodic range, at least compared to what was in the original DM anime. For one, I find the synth is just so damn weak. Horoko and I call it the "My First Casio" version because it literally sounds like a kid playing that theme on their first synth keyboard, to us. It just doesn't hold a candle to the original orchestral arrangement that was played with a live string orchestra that captured all the energy, and majesty of such a theme.

I mean, I hate to be a stickler but I'd really love for the GX remix to completely be replaced in terms of the movie score. The GX remix of that theme is basically, "Diet Passionate Duelists."

Would you be able to do that at least in mine? I'd be thankful forever and ever XDDD

It's cool if you don't like it that much. We can use the original in your version.

And Synchro Summon? Which track is that?

Remember the one that plays in episode 1 when he beats Ushio? That never plays again after episode 12? That's the one and it's awesome.

To be honest, I liked that track as much as I did Dartz somehow being present to see the duel the Pharaoh had against Thief King Bakura.

Which is...not very much

Didn't you say you loved that track on a previous page when I linked you to it? oO Why the sudden change of heart?

Ooooohhh. Would you be able to do that?

Yeah, looping isn't too hard to pull off if you just make two copies of the song on your computer. Or Lance may know an even easier way. It's how I extended Passionate Duelists.

Oh really? Awesome, thank you! That'd be perfect. I'm really curious to see your version too. I know I'm gonna at least be downloading two copies of this movie, mine and then yours.

We'll see how the final versions come out. You may like the third version too, lol.

If it helps somebody did do a pretty damn good recreation on niconico :<.

Yeah, I saw that. It just doesn't sound as good as the original, though, lol.

[Makoeyes987]

I love Jose's theme, but I felt it took up too much time and being split up like it was was kind of awkward to me.

Yeah, I understand. I just can't think of any other at this time. At least now I'll have a reason to go through all my tracks now "for research."

It's cool if you don't like it that much. We can use the original in your version.

Yay!

Remember the one that plays in episode 1 when he beats Ushio? That never plays again after episode 12? That's the one and it's awesome.

Jesus, that's right. That WAS an awesome track. Man, what a shame...

Didn't you say you loved that track on a previous page when I linked you to it? oO Why the sudden change of heart?

The one for Sin Truth Dragon's summoning? Yeah I do like it, but in terms of meshing, it's not quite up there for me. I like it though as a stand alone track and I can appreciate it's place as a homage to Yami Marik, which that whole turn felt like.

While I love most DM tracks and want more to be included, I'm also very...pickiy in terms of where. As much as I love this movie, there's not many points of it that "feel" like DM in terms of tone, appearance or mythology. It's a lot more futuristic and "card gamey." LOL. I know, I'm horribly picky, huh?

Yeah, looping isn't too hard to pull off if you just make two copies of the song on your computer. Or Lance may know an even easier way. It's how I extended Passionate Duelists.

Ahh okay. Awesome!

We'll see how the final versions come out. You may like the third version too, lol.

Going by the work and talent involved, I'm pretty sure of it.

[GymLeaderLance99]

Yeah, looping isn't too hard to pull off if you just make two copies of the song on your computer. Or Lance may know an even easier way. It's how I extended Passionate Duelists.

Actually, I just loop stuff using Movie Maker. I split the track for the parts that'll get repeated/skipped, copy/paste and add a fade and tweak it so it's a smooth transition, and presto. Once I download the movie and see how the music's getting used, I'll find a way to loop it so it fits. It's a good chance for some creativity, lol.

[GoldenUmi]

Wow Mako, that is horribly picky, lol.

Well, we'll make this work in the end. It'll take some time though.

Now excuse me, my new Bakuman chapter awaits me.

[YamiMario]

Oooh, this is pretty interesting. Any chance that the ripped voices/SFX track from the movie could be uploaded somewhere? I'd like to give this a shot as well.

[Ragna]

Wow Mako, that is horribly picky, lol.

It's a trend for us old school fans of the original. When it comes to the original story, we get pretty picky. XD

[GoldenUmi]

Oooh, this is pretty interesting. Any chance that the ripped voices/SFX track from the movie could be uploaded somewhere? I'd like to give this a shot as well.

I'll send it to you through PM.

It's a trend for us old school fans of the original. When it comes to the original story, we get pretty picky. XD

I understand because I am an oldschool fan of the original as well. Although I admittedly love 5D's almost as much as the original. The only thing that knocks it down a bit is the fact that its story is inconsistent.

[Lia]

And behind that picky-ness is hidden a pure excitement and true desire to make things look perfect. xD And obviously they can and will be perfect if bitter fans are dealing with them. xD

[Ryusaki]

A petty comment this may be, but it's going to be at least very slightly amusing to have an official subbed YGO release with the line 'Oh my God' on the same disc as the 4Kids dubbed movie.

[YamiMario]

Just converted the movie into a format Vegas can edit. ohboyohboyohboy this is gonna' be fun.

[Lung]

So, I'm a little lost with what is going on in the thread now, but nonetheless.

I finally got around to watching the movie last night; it felt incredibly short, but I did end up enjoying it in the end. It was nice to see the older characters again. And of course, Pegasus was an absolute riot.

[YamiMario]

Finished making my edit. The whole thing is rendering now, although I have a MP3 file ready and up for grabs if anyone prefers that. PM me to get it.

It was fun to make, and I think it's really something that should satisfy. I've changed pretty much everything. There is only one music track from the original soundtrack left, and it plays at a completely different time, but I won't spoil it, or the rest, bwahahahaha~

[Austin21926]

So, I'm a little lost with what is going on in the thread now, but nonetheless.

I finally got around to watching the movie last night; it felt incredibly short, but I did end up enjoying it in the end. It was nice to see the older characters again. And of course, Pegasus was an absolute riot.

Basically, everybody and their mother is using their editing programs to replace the music in the movie with other tracks from the series that they find more fitting. I can see why they would do it, since the movie's music is mostly from 5Ds, with some from GX, and I don't think any music from the original series was used as all, but I digress.

I watched the movie, courtesy of GoldenUmi, and I liked it as well. It was definitely too short, but it was at least straightforward. The double standard with Judai getting upset at seeing Rainbow Dragon (but not Cyber End) still puzzles me. Weird seeing Yugi not get all up in a huff, since Blue-Eyes had to have been stolen from Kaiba, and he probably would have figured out that Red-Eyes was stolen from his best friend, but oh well.

Junk Gardna has a cool effect, but I would've rather seen another Synchro instead. I liked Neos Knight, though. The duel really should've been longer, but I guess you can only defend against 4000+ attack beatsticks for so long. Judai's enthusiam also made the movie for me. Yusei's stoicism kinda through me off, I guess it's his change in personality in the W.R.G.P. arc that did it, lol.

I liked hearing the "slow" version (for lack of a better term) of that unreleased track "Tactics" when Yusei/Jack/Crow are riding their D-Wheels before Paradox shows up.

And what can I say about Paradox that hasn't been said? He was solid, well-intentioned, hammy ("DON'T TRIFLE WITH ME!") and raised a good argument without being all up-in-my-face with a Hannibal Lecture.

I wished the amount of cameos we got (since other Signers are counted as cameos) from the three series was more even, but I'll live.

I loved the ending shot of the protags + Signers. Wonderful, to say the least.

[Lung]

Ah I see. I believe I heard a "mixed" version of an original piece in there? The Pharaoh's theme.

Frankly, I liked the movie soundtrack, if only because I never really watched GX or 5Ds. Perked me up when I heard the Pharaoh's theme, but still.

Judai was adorable, as always. (:

[Austin21926]

Ah I see. I believe I heard a "mixed" version of an original piece in there? The Pharaoh's theme.

Frankly, I liked the movie soundtrack, if only because I never really watched GX or 5Ds. Perked me up when I heard the Pharaoh's theme, but still.

Judai was adorable, as always. (:

That remix of the track you're referring to (which is called "Passionate Duelists") was actually from the last episode of Yu-Gi-Oh! GX. So technically, there are no original series tracks in the movie (as far as I know)

Also, if memory serves, the GX version of Passionate Duelists plays twice in the movie, so why not use the original Passionate Duelists for one of those two instances? Geez.

[YYugi]

Yusei's stoicism kinda through me off, I guess it's his change in personality in the W.R.G.P. arc that did it, lol.

I didn't find that as a bad thing, I found that rather cute with his Keigo (japanese mannerism ^^), I guess Yuusei being in more duels was what gave him that personality he had in the WRGP wich I also liked very much

I loved the ending shot of the protags + Signers. Wonderful, to say the least.

Completely Agree with this (I should have to wait to my version of the movie to come so I can have it in HD ^^)

Also, if memory serves, the GX version of Passionate Duelists plays twice in the movie, so why not use the original Passionate Duelists for one of those two instances? Geez.

I felt the same, with Yugi's turn as weird as it sound, I didn't have any problem, but I guess it would have fit well with Yami Yugi's appearance.

[Lung]

Oh, so it was a GX remix of an original piece?

I feel robbed now, to be honest.

[Ragna]

Okay, so I guess I'll express my thoughts on the movie now...

The animation was fantastic. Seeing GX with animation like that was nice, since it never really got great animation. lol It was a really nice suprise to see the energetic Judai and the stoic Yusei in this movie, since that's when they're at their best. Yugi had some lines that sounded a bit wierd (mostly the ones about Duel Monsters) but he was still the same epic Dark Yugi for the most part. "Better let me handle this from here, Partner." That was my favorite part of the movie. lol

The duel was nice and fast paced. There were a lot of cool moments in the whole movie, but the Victim Sanctuary part deserves special mention. There was also the classic Dark Yugi moment in "Yusei, I'll get your Stardust Dragon back for you."

I don't mind that we saw more of the 5D's characters than GX or DM characters, because they were the current main cast for the franchise, but the lack of Jonouchi, Anzu, Honda, and Kaiba was criminal! Seeing Ryo and Johan getting their cards stolen would have been nice too. This really boils down to me still feeling cheated when that "10 extra minutes" turned out to be just a ZeXal commercial.

Overall, I was pleased.

Oh my God! OH NOOOOO!

Oh, so it was a GX remix of an original piece?

I feel robbed now, to be honest.

Ha, join the club.

[ChaosYoshiMage]

I watched the movie, courtesy of GoldenUmi, and I liked it as well. It was definitely too short, but it was at least straightforward. The double standard with Judai getting upset at seeing Rainbow Dragon (but not Cyber End) still puzzles me.

I chalked it up to less of a double standard and more of him being more attached to Johan, but then again I ship the two...

[Lia]

Oh, so it was a GX remix of an original piece?

I feel robbed now, to be honest.

For that reason GU replaced the remix with the original, and now it sounds heavenly PERFECT! x)

[natsuari]

I chalked it up to less of a double standard and more of him being more attached to Johan, but then again I ship the two...

I chalk it up to the fact that the writers didn't want to confuse the audience. If he had said "How dare you steal Kaiser's card" the GX savy fans would complain that Sho had inherited it at the end of the series and Ryo didn't have it anymore, if he said "How dare you steal Sho's card" then the audience who had only watched part of the series would wonder why Sho had it since it was Ryo's Ace Card.

And although Yugi did have somewhat of a reaction seeing Kaiba and Jounouchi's monsters, a name drop would have been nice. I kind of hope they do make a second movie, this time with a larger cast, as was suggested in the 10th anniversary book.

[Austin21926]

Considering the enjoyment provided by even a short movie like this one, it really is a shame that the DM, GX and 5D's seemed to miss the point on movies and OVAs. I doubt we'll get much focus on Domino City universe series now that Zexal's out and blanding up the franchise. Hell, they only realised that insert songs were possible by 5D's. A lot of the other popular Shonen anime (we all know what they are) appear to pump movies out at a pretty brisk pace.

Takahashi was wise to refuse to allow Atem to be revived for Yu-Gi-Oh! vs. GX , but apparently nobody told him the movie could still exist without bringing back the dead. That movie is sounding more and more of an appealing prospect these days. I guess it's because I still have nightmares about the Mizoguchi arc of GX.

I don't remember seeing Sherry's butler in GX
But yeah, the Mizuchi arc was kind of... out there?
I'm sad we don't have moar movies.
I would definitely not mind seeing a 5Ds/ZeXal movie sometime down the line.

[Ryusaki]

I don't remember seeing Sherry's butler in GX

That's just my brain trying to forget about the arc.

[YamiMario]

A audio only version of my version of the soundtrack can now be streamed here:
http://soundcloud.com/yami_mario/yu-...d-time/s-LFX9Z

[Nike]

Cool. How about a movie with Resident Evil music?

[GymLeaderLance99]

A audio only version of my version of the soundtrack can now be streamed here:
http://soundcloud.com/yami_mario/yu-...d-time/s-LFX9Z

Overall, it wasn't too bad, and there were some solid choices, but you'll probably need to work on your looping so things aren't awkwardly skipped to, faded out, or placed. Off the top of my head, you threw in that mystery theme from Duelist Kingdom with Yugi and Judai after he brought back Neos Knight, but it didn't really fit while Yugi compliments him, and it was awkwardly shortened. "Speed World" was a good choice, but suffered from the awkward-fade-out issue. Also, if you're going to do what the dub did and have opening/ending songs instead of Makemagic, they should be notable songs from the three series, not just "Road to Tomorrow" and "Future Colors," IMO. I was pleasantly surprised to hear "Road to Tomorrow", but when it switched to "Future Colors"...iunno, I like the song, but I just didn't feel it here. I like the idea, though, so I'll probably think about it for my version.

(Disclaimer: Said awkwardness may not apply to everyone, since I'm just a perfectionist when it comes to this kind of stuff, lol.)

I did like you throwing in "Mystery" from 5D's over the Yusei-at-the-spot scene, "Sad Duel", "Fervent Duel!", "Black Magician", "Calm Before the Duel", "Dark Signers' Duel", "Mysterious" over "Showdown", "Destiny", and some others I'm not remembering, though. Like I said, the looping's really the only thing that needs some work. [/My two cents]

[YamiMario]

Overall, it wasn't too bad, and there were some solid choices, but you'll probably need to work on your looping so things aren't awkwardly skipped to, faded out, or placed. Off the top of my head, you threw in that mystery theme from Duelist Kingdom with Yugi and Judai after he brought back Neos Knight, but it didn't really fit while Yugi compliments him, and it was awkwardly shortened. "Speed World" was a good choice, but suffered from the awkward-fade-out issue. Also, if you're going to do what the dub did and have opening/ending songs instead of Makemagic, they should be notable songs from the three series, not just "Road to Tomorrow" and "Future Colors," IMO. I was pleasantly surprised to hear "Road to Tomorrow", but when it switched to "Future Colors"...iunno, I like the song, but I just didn't feel it here. I like the idea, though, so I'll probably think about it for my version.

(Disclaimer: Said awkwardness may not apply to everyone, since I'm just a perfectionist when it comes to this kind of stuff, lol.)

I did like you throwing in "Mystery" from 5D's over the Yusei-at-the-spot scene, "Sad Duel", "Fervent Duel!", "Black Magician", "Calm Before the Duel", "Dark Signers' Duel", "Mysterious" over "Showdown", "Destiny", and some others I'm not remembering, though. Like I said, the looping's really the only thing that needs some work. [/My two cents]

Thanks. I always appreciate feedback, regardless if it's good or bad.
I tried to somewhat hide my bad looping, but I guess it didn't work out as well as I thought lol. It's hard finding the exact loop point for some of the songs, and with some of them, shorting them down to end without reaching their peak seemed really awkward, and it especially was a problem with Speed World.
I used Road to Tomorrow and Future Colors, mainly because they both symbolize the future. Looking back, I could just have used the full version of Road to Tomorrow and just shortened it down.

I might try to rework some of the loops and ending points of the music, fix some of the missing sound effects and release a second version sometime.

[Ryusaki]

I like the use of The Seal of Orichalcos when Paradox activates Sin World, that's a nice thematic touch.

[GoldenUmi]

A audio only version of my version of the soundtrack can now be streamed here:
http://soundcloud.com/yami_mario/yu-...d-time/s-LFX9Z

Great choices you threw in there. Can't say I agree with all of them, but I see the style you were going for and with some work on looping as Lance mentioned, this should be a great version.

[Makoeyes987]

Any luck with your version(s) GoldenUmi? I eagerly anticipate to see your magic XD

[GoldenUmi]

Any luck with your version(s) GoldenUmi? I eagerly anticipate to see your magic XD

For now I'm waiting on Lance to work his own magic on filtering the other tracks, lol.

Plus, I have so many damn projects I've taken on, plus school and work, so it'll probably take some time. It'll get done, though.

I kind of would prefer to make samples of all of your ideas before I make my own full version.

[YamiMario]

Great choices you threw in there. Can't say I agree with all of them, but I see the style you were going for and with some work on looping as Lance mentioned, this should be a great version.

Ah, thanks, Umi.

[DarkDust_Dragon]

I hate to derail the topic at hand, but I found some interesting animation errors in the movie, specifically Paradox's field being inconsistently drawn. There are three screenshots I took from his fourth turn, during all of which his field should be Sin Truth and Sin Blue-Eyes in attack position, Sin Red-Eyes in Defence Position. The first occurs when Stardust uses its effect:



His Duel Disc had only one monster card on it, probably Sin Truth, leading you to wonder where the other cards went. Then, a moment later, when he declares his attack with Sin Truth:



He now has all three cards, but the awkward angle makes it look like all three are in attack position. And then, another moment later, when Sin Truth's effect destroys their monsters,



He has four monsters in play. Note that in this frame he hasn't revived Sin Stardust with Sin Cross yet. Where did that card come from?

[GoldBlaze]

Basically, everybody and their mother is using their editing programs to replace the music in the movie with other tracks from the series that they find more fitting.

Whoa, nelly. That's a huge deal; why haven't I been following this thread...

Can someone pretty pretty please link up the files/the post of the clean audio version of the film? I love editing stuff.

[NeoArkadia]

Whoa, nelly. That's a huge deal; why haven't I been following this thread...

Can someone pretty pretty please link up the files/the post of the clean audio version of the film? I love editing stuff.

No, they cannot. It is against forum rules, and consider this a warning, mkay?

[GoldBlaze]

Oh poo.

Well, oh well. I'll just listen to the amazing mixes y'all cook up with it.

[pharaohyami5000]

I hate to derail the topic at hand, but I found some interesting animation errors in the movie, specifically Paradox's field being inconsistently drawn.

Hope it's ok I removed the pics from quotes to prevent taking up more space. Are these also from the DVD? Man, 5D's DVDs seem to have re-drawn some of their animation, but couldn't fix the one released from the movie?

It's a true shame none of the unreleased soundtracks are considered for this movie. Would have accepted the Synchro Summon music instead of Yusei Battle when Junk Guardna dropped in, along with many others that could use more tune-ups.

[DarkDust_Dragon]

Hope it's ok I removed the pics from quotes to prevent taking up more space. Are these also from the DVD? Man, 5D's DVDs seem to have re-drawn some of their animation, but couldn't fix the one released from the movie?

Yes; they're from the DVD version. Kinda sad, especially since I found another error from earlier:

When Sin Cyber End is destroyed, we see Sin Rainbow on his Disc sideways, and although its art is hard to see you can tell it's the right card:<br>



But, when Neos Knight goes to attack Sin Rainbow, regular Rainbow Dragon is on his Disc, as shown here:



And to top it off, now those two cards from earlier that we know he was set are nowhere to be seen. Pretty sloppy eh?

It's a true shame none of the unreleased soundtracks are considered for this movie. Would have accepted the Synchro Summon music instead of Yusei Battle when Junk Guardna dropped in, along with many others that could use more tune-ups.

Well, they did use a couple of GX Unreleased Tracks. Shame we didn't get those from 5D's SD3 though.

[Lia]

To be honest a person must have pretty sharp eye to notice those card errors on the duel disks. It depends what fans are eyeing more closely while watching though. I saw some animation redrawn scenes quite easily, but would've never noticed those errors that DarkDust_Dragon exposed. Not that I can fully "see" them even now when they're in front of my eyes, but eh.

[YYugi]

To be honest a person must have pretty sharp eye to notice those card errors on the duel disks. It depends what fans are eyeing more closely while watching though. I saw some animation redrawn scenes quite easily, but would've never noticed those errors that DarkDust_Dragon exposed. Not that I can fully "see" them even now when they're in front of my eyes, but eh.

Agree. These little mistakes aren't that important (atleast for me aren't xD).

But one thing I noticed (because someone pointed it in PDTC ) is that Yuusei has no cards on his hand in the first turn xD

That was a bit weird since until Judai speaks to him we can see he has two cards left but before that he had nothing

I assume that he just draw Road Runner and Bolt Hedgehog from the deck and at some point when Judai and Yugi were amazed he drew the other two
(that or it was a drawing mistake to make him do cool poses without cards )

[DarkDust_Dragon]

To be honest a person must have pretty sharp eye to notice those card errors on the duel disks. It depends what fans are eyeing more closely while watching though. I saw some animation redrawn scenes quite easily, but would've never noticed those errors that DarkDust_Dragon exposed. Not that I can fully "see" them even now when they're in front of my eyes, but eh.

Sorry about that; I probably should have cropped and expanded the images to focus on the cards themselves. And I wasn't even looking for them when I saw them; they were just in the frame long enough for me to notice them and go, "Huh?", so I stopped the movie and looked at them.

One thing I noticed (because someone pointed it in PDTC ) is that Yuusei has no cards on his hand in the first turn

Yep. Just as he draws and reveals Reincarnation of Hope, we can clearly see that he's not holding a hand. Then on Judai's turn, as he reveals Fusion, he has 3 cards instead of 5. And there's probably lots of similar things.

[Lia]

Sorry about that; I probably should have cropped and expanded the images to focus on the cards themselves.

Don't bother. The fact that I can't see the errors doesn't mean that others also can't. May be I'm not so interested in seeing them, so no worries.

And there's probably lots of similar things.

To be honest I have the feeling that the 3 of them don't always hold cards during the entire movie when they should hold. And that's probably because holding cards will restrain Kagami's GORGEOUS HANDS from their incredibly graceful movements.

[YYugi]

Yep. Just as he draws and reveals Reincarnation of Hope, we can clearly see that he's not holding a hand. Then on Judai's turn, as he reveals Fusion, he has 3 cards instead of 5. And there's probably lots of similar things.

I noticed that searching for cards errors xD

To be honest I have the feeling that the 3 of them don't always hold cards during the entire movie when they should hold. And that's probably because holding cards will restrain Kagami's GORGEOUS HANDS from their incredibly graceful movements.

Well, for Yuusei's first turn we can say that, but for the other moments they are with their fists in the hand were they hold the cards. (sorry if I didn't make that clear)

But at the end of the turn, the only one that got cards left was Yugi, so Judai and Yuusei didn't have to had cards on their hands after that.

[Nike]

I pre-ordered the movie from Amazon UK. It should come to my house in August. What I don't understand is that why is there such thing as the uncut English dubbed version of the movie only on the UK DVD?

[Ryusaki]

What I don't understand is that why is there such thing as the uncut English dubbed version of the movie only on the UK DVD?

Because in the UK we don't **** around.

[63cohen]

I like to think of it more as 4kids in the UK not being as affected by the lawsuit as 4kids in NYC. Or perhaps a prearranged deal with MangaUK to distribute the DVD in Europe was already in place before the lawsuit came up, while 4kids was planning on doing it themselves in America.

Or, perhaps the movie license and the Yugioh license are separate.

[Nike]

Wow. There's an uncut 4Kids' dub with no edits, cards in Japanese. Only on UK DVD.

[pharaohyami5000]

Yep. Just as he draws and reveals Reincarnation of Hope, we can clearly see that he's not holding a hand. Then on Judai's turn, as he reveals Fusion, he has 3 cards instead of 5. And there's probably lots of similar things.

Wow. Were the animators really in this much of a rush to finish the movie? This is what I hate about deadlines. There's no escaping errors. I know Paradox did a misplay but I didn't understand why the monster-destroying effect, after Sin Blue-Eyes sicked Black Magician, was reflected by Stardust instead of just vanishing? May someone please fill me in here?

[dragosix]

Wow. Were the animators really in this much of a rush to finish the movie? This is what I hate about deadlines. There's no escaping errors. I know Paradox did a misplay but I didn't understand why the monster-destroying effect, after Sin Blue-Eyes sicked Black Magician, was reflected by Stardust instead of just vanishing? May someone please fill me in here?

Stardust's effect negates and destroys the card.